Metal 3D Printing vs CNC Machining vs Metal Casting: A Complete Comparison Guide

Banner Image Courtesy of 3Dnatives

Metal 3D Printing, CNC Machining, and Metal Casting Explained

Metal 3D Printing (Additive Manufacturing)

Metal 3D printing builds parts layer by layer using powdered metals fused by lasers, electron beams, or binding agents. Popular technologies include:

• Selective Laser Melting (SLM) and Direct Metal Laser Sintering (DMLS): lasers melt metal powder into solid layers.

• Binder Jetting: a liquid binder glues powder particles, later sintered in a furnace.

• Electron Beam Melting (EBM): uses an electron beam instead of a laser.

Metal 3D printing enables complex geometries, lightweight structures, and rapid prototyping. Materials range from stainless steel and titanium to aluminum and super alloys.

CNC Machining (Subtractive Manufacturing)

CNC machining removes material from a solid block (metal billet) using computer‑controlled cutting tools. Common processes include:

• Milling: rotating cutters remove material to create shapes.

• Turning: lathes spin the workpiece while cutting tools shape it.

• Drilling: precise holes are created.

CNC machining is prized for precision, repeatability, and versatility. It works with almost any machinable metal, from aluminum and brass to hardened steels.

Metal Casting

Casting involves pouring molten metal into a mold, letting it cool and solidify. Variants include:

• Sand Casting: inexpensive, flexible, ideal for large parts.

• Investment Casting: wax patterns create detailed molds for complex shapes.

• Die Casting: molten metal injected into steel molds for high‑volume production.

Casting is one of the oldest manufacturing methods, valued for scalability and cost efficiency in mass production.

Pros and Cons of Each Method

Metal 3D Printing

Pros

• Enables intricate geometries impossible with traditional methods

• Rapid prototyping and customization

• Lightweight designs with internal lattices

• Minimal material waste

Cons

• High per‑part cost compared to machining or casting

• Limited scalability for mass production

• Requires post‑processing (heat treatment, machining, polishing)

• Smaller build volumes than casting or machining

CNC Machining

Pros

• Extremely high precision and tight tolerances

• Wide material compatibility

• Mature, reliable technology with global availability

• Excellent surface finish with proper tooling

Cons

• Material waste due to the subtractive process

• Less efficient for highly complex geometries

• Set up time and tooling costs for new designs

• Not ideal for very high‑volume production compared to casting

Metal Casting

Pros

• Cost‑effective for large production runs

• Strong mechanical properties from solidification

• Suitable for very large parts

• Wide range of alloys available

Cons

• Long lead times for mold design and setup

• Limited design flexibility compared to 3D printing

• Surface finish often requires machining or polishing

• Dimensional accuracy is lower than CNC machining

Comparison by Key Factors

Best Applications

Metal 3D Printing

• Aerospace: lightweight brackets, turbine components

• Medical: patient‑specific implants, surgical tools

• Automotive: prototypes, performance parts

• Research: experimental designs, rapid iteration

CNC Machining

• Automotive: precision engine components, transmission parts

• Industrial: tooling, fixtures, custom equipment

• Defense: high‑tolerance parts for weapons systems

• Consumer products: electronics housings, luxury goods

Metal Casting

• Automotive: engine blocks, cylinder heads

• Industrial: pumps, valves, heavy machinery parts

• Jewelry: intricate designs via investment casting

• Large‑scale production: cookware, hardware, construction components

Choose the Right One for Your Projects

Choose Metal 3D Printing if:

• You need prototypes or low‑volume production

• Your design involves complex geometries or lightweight structures

• Customization is critical (e.g., medical implants)

Choose CNC Machining if:

• You require high precision and tight tolerances

• You’re producing small to medium batches

• Material versatility is important

Choose Metal Casting if:

• You’re producing large volumes of parts

• Cost efficiency is a priority

• Part size is large or requires strong mechanical properties